Eph All-Americans since 1989
# = NCAA Champion
* = First Eph 4-Time All-American
| Year | Runner |
| 2008 | Edgar Kosgey |
| Jeff Perlis | |
| 2005 | Neal Holtschulte * # |
| Stephen Wills | |
| 2004 | Neal Holtschulte |
| 2003 | Neal Holtschulte |
| Matt Winkler | |
| 2002 | Neal Holtschulte |
| Karl Remsen | |
| 2000 | Tim Campbell |
| Andy Golden | |
| Dusty Lopez | |
| 1999 | Tim Campbell |
| 1998 | Paul Alsdorf |
| Dan McCue | |
| 1997 | Paul Alsdorf |
| 1996 | Paul Alsdorf |
| Tim Billo | |
| Matt Buck | |
| 1995 | Tim Billo |
| Keith Long | |
| Jeremie Perry | |
| Marzuki Stevens | |
| 1994 | Tim Billo |
| Keith Long | |
| Jeremie Perry # | |
| Marzuki Stevens | |
| Creaghan Trainor | |
| 1989 | Marc Beitz |
