NCAA Division III Tournament record through March, 2011
11-7 (.611)
| Coach | Appearances | Record |
| Pat Manning | 7 | 11-7 (.611) |
| Year | Opponent | Result | Score | Coach |
| 2013 | Scranton | Won | 79-59 | Pat Manning |
| Rochester | Won | 68-60 | ||
| Ithaca |
Won | 64-60 OT |
||
| Whitman | Won | 63-53 |
||
| DePauw | Lost | 59-56 |
NCAA Semifinals | |
| Amherst |
3rd Place Game |
|||
| 2011 | Muhlenberg | Lost | 64-63 | Pat Manning |
| 2010 | Mt. St. Mary (NY) | Won | 62-56 | Pat Manning |
| DeSales | Won | 94-77 | ||
| Amherst | Lost | 71-66 | Sectional Semifinals | |
| 2007 | Southern Me. | Lost | 68-62 | Pat Manning |
| 2006 | NYU | Won | 63-56 | Pat Manning |
| Messiah | Won | 71-67 | ||
| Baldwin Wallace | Lost | 71-65 | Sectional Finals | |
| 1999 | Bowdoin | Won | 72-58 | Pat Manning |
| Rowan | Won | 62-56 | ||
| Salem State | Lost | 76-60 | Sectional Finals | |
| 1997 | Salem St. | Won | 80-66 | Pat Manning |
| Southern Me. | Lost | 68-61 | Second Round |
