| Year | Athlete |
| 1999 | Rebecca Brooks |
| 1997 | Kirsten Paquette |
| Meg Randall | |
| 1996 | Kirsten Paquette |
| Meg Randall | |
| 1995 | Yvonne Barnes |
| Lisa Chadderon | |
| Carrie Elson | |
| Kirsten Paquette | |
| Jessica Racusin | |
| Meg Randall | |
| Brenda Start | |
| Alyssa Trzeszkowski | |
| 1994 | Yvonne Barnes |
| 1992 | Sue Donna |
| Lee Kiechel | |
| Cherie Macauley | |
| 1991 | Rebecca Adams |
| Kira Shields | |
| 1990 | Ann Bokman |
| Ann Danhauer | |
| Anne Platt | |
| 1989 | Dawn Macauley |
| Ann Danhauer | |
| Anne Platt |
